Blog
Training That Counts (and Training That Doesn't)
Nearly every cyber-insurance application asks whether you train your people. In our review of 13 public carrier applications (November 2026), 12 asked about security-awareness training, phishing tests, or both.
Phishing is the fake email, text or call designed to get someone to click a link, open a file, hand over a password or move money. It works because it targets people, not machines, and people are busy.
The good news is that this is one of the cheaper boxes on the form to tick honestly. The less good news is that the better applications no longer accept "we have an annual video" as the whole answer.
What carriers actually ask
Read across the forms, and the questions get specific:
- How often? Beazley asks how often you run interactive phishing training and simulated phishing emails. Markel asks how often campaigns run.
- Simulations, not just slides? Tokio Marine HCC asks specifically about social-engineering training that includes phishing simulations, meaning fake phishing emails sent to your own staff to see who clicks.
- What happens after someone clicks? Beazley asks whether people who fail get extra training.
- Who gets more? Markel asks whether people with elevated access, such as administrators and anyone who can move money, get extra practice.
Corvus, At-Bay, Chubb, Cowbell, Hartford, CFC and AIG all want a straight answer on annual training, simulated phishing or both.
Why the carriers care
Insurers see where claims start, and a large share of them start with a person being fooled: a stolen password typed into a fake login page, a malicious attachment, or a convincing request to pay an invoice. Training won't make anyone perfect. But it makes people slower to click, quicker to report, and more comfortable saying, "This looks odd, can someone check?"
That last part matters most. The best outcome of a phishing program isn't nobody clicking. It's somebody reporting the strange email within minutes, so IT can pull it from everyone else's inbox.
What the honest picture usually looks like
When I ran IT at a company of about 200 people, the honest version of training looked like this for a long time. New hires got a short talk on day one. The annual online course got finished in a scramble near the deadline. And if a broker had asked for the last phishing-test result, nobody could have produced it.
None of that is unusual, and none of it is a moral failing. It's what happens when training is treated as a compliance chore instead of a habit.
Training that counts
Short and frequent beats long and annual. A few minutes every month or quarter keeps the topic alive. An hour once a year is forgotten by spring.
Simulations that look like your real mail. A fake package-delivery notice is fine. A fake invoice from a vendor you really use, or a fake document-share from your own file system, teaches more because it's what attackers actually send.
An easy way to report. One button in Outlook or Gmail that sends a suspicious message to IT. If reporting takes three steps, people won't do it.
A kind response to a click. People who click get a short, private follow-up lesson. Public shaming teaches people to hide mistakes, and hidden mistakes are the expensive ones.
Extra attention for the people attackers target. Finance, HR, executives and anyone with administrator access see more targeted phishing and should get more practice. That includes the CEO.
Training that doesn't count
- A video nobody watched all the way through, with no record of who completed it.
- A once-a-year phishing test with results nobody looks at.
- A policy document signed at hiring and never mentioned again.
- Training that skips the owners and executives because they're "too busy."
None of those will hold up well if a carrier or a big customer asks for evidence.
Keep the receipts
The forms ask about frequency and follow-up because those can be shown. Most training platforms produce simple reports: who completed which course, when, and how phishing tests went over time. Save a copy each quarter. If a carrier, a big customer or an auditor asks, you'll have a dated answer instead of a guess.
Watch the trend, not just the click rate. A falling click rate is good. A rising report rate is better, because it means people are acting as your early-warning system.
Free and low-cost starting points
You don't need a big budget to begin. CISA publishes free, plain-language guidance on recognizing phishing at cisa.gov, and its Secure Our World program has short materials suitable for staff. Many IT providers bundle a training and phishing-simulation platform into their service, so ask what yours includes before buying separately.
What to do Monday morning
- Find three dates: the last company-wide security training, the last phishing test, and the completion rate for each.
- If you haven't run a phishing test in the past year, ask your IT provider or a training vendor to schedule one this month.
- Decide in advance what happens when someone clicks: a short private lesson, not a public callout. Tell staff that's the policy.
- Make sure there's a one-click way to report a suspicious email, and that someone actually reads the reports.
- Put finance, HR and the executive team on the list for extra practice, including yourself.
Shorehelm's readiness assessment asks for these training dates the same way the carriers do.